HomeMy WebLinkAboutSRB OIS 17-009 (2)_RedactedLONG BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
HOMICIDE DETAIL
Shooting Review Board
17-009
Non-fatal Hit Officer-Involved Shooting
DR 17-47116
Investigated by:
Detective Scott Lasch
Detective Teryl Hubert
Detective Michael Hubbard
Sergeant Megan Zabel
Presented by:
Sergeant John Magallanes
Any notes taken during the
meeting are for the sole
purpose of this discussion
Note Taking
This presentation is intended to
provide a summary of the
incident only and is not a
complete record of all
interviews, statements, or
evidence.The actual case file
contains all interviews,
statements, and evidence related
to this incident.Review Board Presentation
SynopsisDate:
Lighting:
Weather:
August 6, 2017 @ 23:38 hours
Night time, street lights, interior lights.
Clear
Location:
Summary:
Officers dispatched to a 245 stabbing at
Place, locate a injured female victim who tells them another
woman is being held by the suspect at 9th/Washington.
Officers locate suspect and 2nd victim being held hostage,
SWAT activated and during negotiation with the suspect an
OIS occurs.
•22:48:13 –245 Call entered into CAD
•22:50:21 –1A67 Dispatched
•22:54:11 –1S29 On scene with 1st victim
•22:59:34 –Setting up on
•23:03:35 –Units observe suspect holding a knife to the victim’s throat and head
•23:14:01 –Male victim exits location into PD custody
•23:15:01 –K5 (Moscoso) on scene per CAD
•23:19:01 –On duty Hostage Negotiator on scene
•23:27:26 –YS1 requests second page for full SWAT
activation.
•23:38:50 –998 and hostage rescue
Timeline
Map of Incident
10th Street
9th Street Washington Place Martin Luther King Jr. Avenue N
(Target)
911 Call
Radio
(edited)Olive Avenue
1st 664-187 Victim
1st 664-187 Victim
1st 664-187 Victim
Map of Incident
EAT #2
TARGET
EAT #1N
Sketch
Officer Ed Moscoso
Unit: K5
Vehicle: 18024
DID: 6164
Hired: 6/2/2003
Uniform: K9 BDU
Weapon: AR-15
Last qualification: 7/12/2016
Rounds discharged: 1
Other Force used: None
Injuries: None
Involved Officer
Cleveland Henderson
Age: 43 at time of shooting
Weapon: Stabbing Instrument
Suspect Info known at time of OIS
664-187 Vic/Hostage
3rd 245 Vic/Hostage
Moscoso’s Perspective
Approximately 72’ 1”
•I arrived at and observed a
female victim with numerous facial wounds sitting on
the front porch.
•Victim… then stated, “Cleveland did this, and there is
still a girl inside, it's the house on 9th Street." One of
the subjects who was standing behind Victim... then
stated, "It's the corner house,“
•I then responded to the intersection of 9th Street and
Washington Place. I observed on
the south/east corner. I illuminated the residence with both of my vehicles spotlights and heard loud screams coming from inside of .
Excerpts from Trout’s Report
•Communications Center began attempting to call inside the residence and I began using my vehicle's PA system announcing for the subjects inside to walk out the front door and contact the nearest police officer.
•As Officers began showing up in the intersection, I set up a containment around the residence. Officer M. Soldin #5149 had taken an advantage position across from (south/west corner of 9th Street and Washington Place) and observed the front door open.
•Officer Soldin then notified me that he had a suspect holding a knife to a victim's neck inside of .
Excerpts from Trout’s Report
•At this time in the incident, I was the Incident Commander. I told Sergeant J. Lacey to supervise
the primary EAT and I notified the
Communications Center that we had Hostage Rescue situation and needed a SWAT (Special
Weapons and Tactics) activation. I then moved to 9th Street and Olive Avenue to set up Command
Post.
•Sergeant S. Hunt #5532 arrived on scene at the
Command Post and I immediately assigned him
to supervise a 2nd EAT (Emergency Action Team) at 9th and Washington Place.
Excerpts from Trout’s Report
•I arrived at the intersection of 9th Street and Washington Place.
•Officer Soldin arrived on scene and took a position on the west sidewalk, directly in front of the front door of . Officer Soldin was kneeling behind the hood of a compact sedan that provided him cover while he looked through the front entry way of .
•Officer Soldin stated, "He has a knife to her head!" I walked over to Officer Soldin's location and noticed that his position offered him a clear view into the living room and back bedroom of I observed the suspect holding a female victim around the neck.
Excerpts from Lacey’s Report
•Officer Soldin asked to grab the AR-15 out of Sergeant Trout's vehicle. I unlocked the AR-15 and handed it to Officer Soldin. Officer Soldinstated that if he had an opportunity, he wanted to fire a shot in order to eliminate the immediate threat that the suspect posed to the victim.
•I told Officer Soldin that I did not want him taking a shot with the victim so close to the suspect because he had never fired the rifle that he was currently holding, and did not know the settings of his rifle. I believed that allowing Officer Soldinto fire a rifle that he was not familiar with was too risky with the victim so close to the suspect.
Excerpts from Lacey’s Report
•However, the rifle was still a viable option if the suspect separated himself from the victim, so I
allowed Officer Soldin to keep the rifle deployed.
•Officer Manis, Officer Soldin, and Officer
Prebanda were at the hood of the compact
vehicle, looking directly into the suspect's location.
•Officer Schaefer, Officer Batres, Officer Gonzales, and approximately two other officers were set up
as an EAT at the trunk of the compact vehicle. From their position, they could not see inside of
the residence.
Excerpts from Lacey’s Report
•I quickly briefed the officers on the EAT and
the officers… I stated that if the suspect began
to stab the victim the EAT would approach the
suspect's location and enter the residence to
deal with any threat and rescue the victim.
•If the suspect moved into another part of the
residence and left the victim in the bedroom
the EAT would not look to follow the suspect,
but would enter the residence and extract the
victim.
Excerpts from Lacey’s Report
•Officer Hodgson arrived on scene and deployed his AR-15. I ordered Officer Soldin to sling his rifle because Officer Hodgson had his personal rifle with him and was more familiar with it. I asked Officer Hodgson, "If you have an opportunity, can you take a shot?" Officer Hodgson said he did not think he could get a clear shot on the suspect from his current location, and that the suspect and victim were moving around too much.
•I ordered Officer Hodgson to deploy his rifle north of the residence, facing south. This location gave him a view into the kitchen of the residence.
•This would allow him to possibly take a shot if an opportunity presented itself, and would take the EAT out of his line of fire. I then told the officers at the hood of the vehicle that if the suspect began to stab the victim, that the EAT would enter to rescue the victim, and that the officers at the hood were not to fire their weapons.
Excerpts from Lacey’s Report
•Officer Moscoso arrived on scene with his AR-15. He stated to me that if he had enough space he wanted to take a shot to eliminate any threat to the victim. I stated that he had my approval to take a shot if the opportunity presented itself.
•I briefed the officers at the front of the vehicle and the EAT. I stated that if Officer Moscoso has an opportunity that he would take a shot and attempt to eliminate the threat. I told them not to approach on Officer Moscoso's shot, but to wait until he said "go."
•After the initial brief I repeated the details of the plan both to the EAT and to the officers at the front of the hood, and ensured that every member of the team knew their assignment and had a clear understanding of the plan.
Excerpts from Lacey’s Report
•I heard Sgt R. Trout advise that he was on
scene and that the victim was a female and
she had been stabbed in head and shoulder.
•Sgt Trout stated via police radio that officers
on scene could see the suspect and he was
actively holding a knife to the throat and head
of a victim.
•Sgt Trout stated that the suspect had been
given numerous commands to drop the knife
and the female victim continued to scream.
Excerpts from Moscoso’s Report
•While still driving to the incident, I feared that
it was only a matter of time before the
suspect seriously injured or killed the victim.
•I took a position behind a vehicle parked on
the south west corner of 9th St and
Washington Pl.
•I could see that the residence also had a metal
security screen door that was also open. The
front door to the residence was approximately
25 yards from my position.
Excerpts from Moscoso’s Report
•Through the front door I could see a male
black wearing a dark colored shirt with his left
arm wrapped around a female holding her in
front of him. The lights were on in the
residence, allowing me to see inside with good detail…I noted the female was wearing a
grey shirt.
•She appeared listless with both arms hanging
at her side and her head slumped forward and
canted slightly to the left. I feared that she
was already severely injured and in need of immediate medical aide…
Excerpts from Moscoso’s Report
•Ofc C. Manis was kneeling directly to my left and was armed with only a handgun. Ofc Manis told me that the suspect had already stabbed one female and was now holding another female hostage with a knife. He then pointed in the direction of the front door at and stated, "They are right there, do you see them? He's holding the knife in his right hand right now, can you see it?"
•I indicated to Ofc Manis that I could see them and I asked him if there was anybody else in the house. Ofc Manis stated, "No, it's just them now. He keeps saying he's going to kill her. He keeps walking around erratically".
Excerpts from Moscoso’s Report
•I asked Ofc Manis who was in charge of this EAT and he stated, "Sgt Lacey". Ofc Manis then
directed Sgt Lacey to my right side.
•I asked Sgt Lacey if there was an original victim to
this incident. Sgt Lacey stated, "Yes, she was
stabbed in head and shoulder and she was transported to the hospital. He is now holding a
knife to this female's throat".
•This exchange with Sgt Lacey confirmed my
feeling that this situation was dire and the female victim currently being held by the suspect was in
need of immediate help.
Excerpts from Moscoso’s Report
•I told Sgt Lacey that if I had the opportunity to
immediately stop the suspect's action with a shot from
my rifle I was going to take it. Sgt Lacey agreed and
stated, "OK. I will tell the EAT to move in on your shot".
•While looking through the optic of my rifle I could see
the suspect clenching what I believed to be a knife his
right hand. His fist gripped it tightly and I could only see two or three inches of gray or silver metal exposed above his thumb and fore finger.
•He would occasionally raise his closed fist to the female's neck, resting his thumb just under her chin. This put the blade of the knife against the skin of her neck.
Excerpts from Moscoso’s Report
•Several times the suspect would yell out. I was
only able to understand some of the things he
was saying. This included, "I'm going to kill
her. You're going to have to kill me. I'm not
coming out.“
•Because the suspects actions were
continuous, negotiations were failing and he
had just stabbed another woman in head, I
felt that if I did not put a stop to him
immediately, he was going to kill the woman
he had hostage.
Excerpts from Moscoso’s Report
•While looking through my optic, the suspect
suddenly leaned to his right while simultaneously
extending his left arm to his left.
•This created an approximately 12 inch space
between the head of the suspect and the head of
the female hostage. I believed this could be my
only opportunity to stop the suspect.
•I knew that a well-placed shot to the suspect's
head would render him immediately neutral. This
would end the situation and allow the EAT to
rescue the hostage.
Excerpts from Moscoso’s Report
•I placed the reticle of my optic in the center of
the suspects head. I fired my service rifle and
the suspect immediately fell forward and out
of my view. The hostage also fell forward and
slightly to the left.
•I knew that my bullet had hit its intended
target and the hostage could not be further
injured by the suspect. I put my rifle on safe
and in a loud voice yelled, "Go go go".
Indicating to the EAT to enter the residence. I
maintained my position behind the vehicle.
Excerpts from Moscoso’s Report
•I heard Officer Moscoso fire his rifle. The EAT began
moving towards the suspect's location. I knew that in
order to get into the residence they would have to
cross Officer Moscoso's line of fire, and I did not know if Officer Moscoso was done firing his rifle. I ordered the EAT to hold their position, and they stopped advancing.
•Officer Moscoso then said, "Go!" I then relayed, the same order to the EAT and yelled, "Go!" The EAT advanced on the residence.
•I approached the location with the EAT and aired, "998, EAT is making entry into the residence.“ The EAT entered the residence and extracted the victim.
Excerpts from Lacey’s Report
9th/Washington Pl. Video (cropped)
Video (cropped & ½ speed)
Weapon
Suspect Injuries
Suspect Injuries
Suspect’s X-Ray
Suspect Injuries
Cleveland Henderson
Age: 43 at time of shooting
Gang Affiliation: None Documented
Status: 24 years state prison
Injuries: GSW to face
Weapon: Stabbing Instrument
Rounds discharged: N/A
Other Force used: N/A
Charges: 2 Counts of Attempt Murder, 2 Counts of False Imprisonment, 1 Count of Assault with a Deadly Weapon
PRCS Status: On Parole ADW-Sex offender –With Ankle Bracelet
Suspect
Cleveland Henderson
Age: 45
Gang Affiliation: None Documented
5150 History:
•10/2016 –, Henderson was at
the 7-11 wielding a hammer stating voices
were telling him to kill himself. Was placed on
a 5150 hold.
•04/2017 –, Henderson
stated he was paranoid schizophrenic and
wanted to stab people following him. Kitchen
knife was recovered from his waistband. Was
placed on a 5150 hold. Suspect
LASD Toxicology
•Conduct a debrief of the incident with Officers Gary Hodgson, Ed Moscoso, and Sergeants Jason Lacey and Robert Trout. Oct 4 & 5, 2017
•Academy to ensure any employee who is AR-15 qualified and fails to qualify shall be notified they are decertified until they do qualify and that they may not carry or deploy an AR-15. Dec 12, 2017
•Amend the existing AR-15 policy to require annual maintenance of all AR-15 rifles owned by the department or carried by department personnel. The annual maintenance shall include sighting in the weapons. In addition, look at the feasibility of placing some type of sticker on the weapons to indicate the last time they were inspected/sighted in. Dec 12, 2017
TRAINING DIVISION PROJECTS
•Provide in-service training to department personnel
regarding the effectiveness of ballistics for both
handgun/rifle's as well as the need for annual
maintenance of rifles including the optics. Dec 1, 2017
•Sergeants Gallo and Nydel to work with Field Support
to take over the tracking of AR-15 certified personnel
and weapon inventory from SWAT and move that function under the Academy/Range. Dec 12, 2017
•Academy range staff to take over the
certification/approvals for all AR-15 weapons and hardware attached to them before an officer can deploy them, including ensuring the weapons are sighted in. Dec 12, 2017
TRAINING DIVISION PROJECTS
•Body Worn Camera Administrator Sergeant J. Gludt to conduct a review of Officer Gary Hodgson and Eric Cornell who both indicate their camera failed to record during this OIS and determine the cause of the problem. Determine if the failure to record was a hardware related and if work with the vendor to resolve the issue. If the issue is determined to be employee error and they should have been recording under the policy, notify Patrol Bureau Deputy Chief Beckman and obtain direction on how to proceed. As part of this review, also determine if there were any other officers involved in the incident that were carrying body cameras that should have been recording but failed to and notify Deputy Chief Beckman for further direction on a course of action to take. Aug 16, 2017
PATROL BUREAU PROJECTS
•Patrol Bureau to work with Investigations Bureau
regarding the large number of officers at this scene and
determine if they were required by Homicide for an
investigative purpose and if not why they were not released back into service. Sept 6, 2017
•Reissue a watch report reminding ALL department
personnel not to call the Communications Center supervisors line or communications personnel immediately following or during a critical incident such as an officer involved shooting or hostage incident
merely to inquire what is going on or receive a briefing.
Only phone calls directly related to operations that are
necessary should occur. Sept 7, 2017
PATROL BUREAU PROJECTS
•Notify all Patrol Sergeants and Lieutenants to
request SWAT over the radio so on-duty
personnel are aware of an activation. Sept 6,
2017
PATROL BUREAU PROJECTS
•Prepare a recommendation to conduct
refresher AR-15 course for existing/trained
department personnel who carry AR-15 rifles
Sept 8, 2017
•Provide recommendation on modifications to
the existing MET program to include being
proactive and focusing on specific individuals
with on-going mental health issues to try and
provide services to them on a proactive basis.
Sept 14, 2017
FIELD SUPPORT PROJECTS
•Communications to provide training to all
Communications Supervisors regarding
making SWAT callouts a priority and ensuring
they know how to utilize the call-out system.
Sept 6, 2017
•Communications personnel will ensure any
SWAT activation is broadcast on all police
frequencies to ensure on-duty personnel are
aware of an activation. Aug 30, 2017
COMMUNICATIONS PROJECTS
LONG BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
HOMICIDE DETAIL
Shooting Review Board
17-009
Non-fatal Hit Officer-Involved Shooting
DR 17-47116
Investigated by:
Detective Scott Lasch
Detective Teryl Hubert
Detective Michael Hubbard
Sergeant Megan Zabel
Presented by:
Sergeant John Magallanes